Philadelphia, PA: P.Y.T.’s “P.Y.T. Burger”


The Piazza at Schmidt’s
1050 N Hancock St
Philadelphia, PA 19123
(215) 268-7825

A few people are talking about this place online…just a few – read here, here, herehere, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here (the rest of the world still has Crystal Pepsi?  Seriously?  Damn!), here, here, here, here and oh, here.   Holy word of mouth!  Well, if there is one thing legendary Philly party-promoter Tommy Up knows how to do it is get people talking and with his latest venture, the uber-hip restaurant/lounge P.Y.T., it is clear another thing Up can do really well is run a burger joint.

Self-described as a California style burger bar, P.Y.T. as a concept is well thought out and its location in the middle of Bart Blatstein’s Piazza At Schmidt’s is both ideal and logical.  Indoor seating in stylish booths and at the sleek bar will be more popular in colder months, but on a gorgeous day like we had (a rare example of the idea that it is “Always Sunny in Philadelphia”) the piazza-side tables with lime green umbrellas were the place to be.

I modified my P.Y.T. Burger (toppings are key here) and was able to snap a few pics before eagerly diving in to devour  the 1/3 lb.(ish) of beef blanketed (but not buried or overpowered) with a fried egg (preparation nailed – just the slightest bit of yolk ooze), bacon, lettuce, tomato (bright red!), onions, cheese (great melt) and a devilishly sweet onion & mayo secret sauce (note to Colgate – this would make the perfect toothpaste flavor).  The burger was heavily seasoned and cooked around the range I requested, not pegged, but to the rarer which is a 1000 times better than going too far.  The completed burger stacked pretty high, but everything squished together well and was pretty manageable to eat in mixed company.

DSC_0028As good as the burgers are, the P.Y.T. sign also promotes two other strengths of the restaurant.  If the “T: thing” is the burger and the “Y:young” is the music (djs, Steely Dan’s “Kid Charlemagne” was playing as we were leaving – probably not stereotypical but it worked for a Sunday), then “P: pretty” is a really great way to describe the drinks.

With a tip of the hat to the history of the area, P.Y.T. offers cherry sodas (and cherry cokes) mixed special for the under-21 set (and or those feeling a bit guilty about imbibing so early in the day).  For those old enough there are adult milkshakes that may become the calling card of the restaurant.  DSC_0001Offered in 3 varieties they were the perfect mix of ice cream pleasures and alcoholic zing….. my “Jack Rabbit Slim” vanilla shake, spun with a healthy mix of Maker’s Mark, was impossibly simple yet incredibly complex in taste.  Not overpowering or “boozy,” the shake was light and airy and instantly brought smiles to our faces.

Brunch ended with strawberry mojitos and that warm and fuzzy glow of a great meal shared in good company.

Up’s place is still in soft-open mode and the addition of a POS machine and a few more weeks with the layout of the joint may help the flow.  I truly appreciated our server’s enthusiasm for the menu.  I gotta say, I love it when the wait staff is as excited about what you are ordering as you are.  It is clear Up (and his team) spent some time in training making sure that the staff understood it is ok to be themselves.  P.Y.T. is to a degree about the scene and the servers fit the part straight from central casting, but everyone we came into contact with had a personality, a smile and enthusiasm for what they were doing – that is rare and is a testament to Up and his history creating a vibe.

Thanks to Jess from Philly’s favorite burger blog  Fries With That Shake for inviting me to the special food blogger tasting and “E” from Foodaphilia for the great conversation.


10 thoughts on “Philadelphia, PA: P.Y.T.’s “P.Y.T. Burger”

  1. Thanks for the props. I enjoyed reading your post as well. The food was amazing. It was definitely an interesting scene. Would be pretty cool if this became the norm for new openings.

  2. Pingback: I Want To Love You PYT

  3. Pingback: PYT – reopens at 5 pm this evening…

  4. Pingback: Round ‘em up, 26 July

  5. Have you been back since the “soft opening”? Food still on point… service continues to be horrendous. Always at least 6 clueless servers & food runners wandering around, have to track down whoever is considered to be a hostess, & more times than not, get yourself a menu if you don’t want to wait 15min for your first visit from the waitress. This isn’t reflective of just 1-2 visits on my part either, it’s their standard. Your troupe of VIP foodies obviously got some special treatment!

    • I’m not certain that we received “special treatment” but I will note that we went off-hours, which might have made our situation different than yours. I have been surprised by the number of negative reviews of PYT and have not been back since the soft launch (more a result of the nasty weather everytime we try to go than anything else). That last mile is such a huge issue for all businesses, not just restaurants.

      I tend to forgive some service issues when the food is, as you noted, “on point.” We hit Butcher & Singer twice last week. The first time the server was tremendous. She made a great meal even better. The second trip the service was not “Starr” quality, but the food overcame it. It sounds like you are willing to forgive some as well, since you state you have made a few trips. At certain price points that becomes more difficult to do, so I can’t blame you being a bit ticked off. I’d like to think that the managers you spoke with (and maybe even Tommy Up if he was available) were quick to address your concerns.

      Thanks for your comments, Erin. I think PYT fills a niche (a great bar with a good burger) and I am interested to see where they decide to take their business.

  6. To me, it is all hype. I waited almost an hour before I got my food (the place wasn’t busy). It took so long that we almost left. The food was average at best and pretty pricey. I won’t be going back again.

    • Thanks for your comment, Craig.

      Hype is part of it, for sure. I think Tommy Up would agree (a large part of their success is tied up in creating a scene/vibe). I’m going to sneak back soon and I’ll post again.

  7. Pingback: PYT « Messy and Picky

  8. Pingback: Fast Food Burgers in Hipsterland, PYT, Philadelphia

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s